Translate

How Wide Is Wide Enough? What the Science Says About Streamside Buffers

Banner Image of How Wide Is Wide Enough? What the Science Says About Streamside Buffers

In my last post, I explained how streamside buffers fight flooding by managing volume and velocity. The natural next question is one I’ve heard from township supervisors, developers, and landowners alike: how wide does a buffer need to be?

For a long time, nobody could give a straight answer. Minimum width standards varied from state to state and even by programs, ranging from 35 to 100 feet. Then researchers right here in Pennsylvania took on the question.

In 2014, scientists at the Stroud Water Research Center in Avondale, Chester County, published what has become the go-to review on buffer width. They reviewed 238 scientific studies across eight factors, including nitrate removal, sediment trapping, erosion protection, temperature control, woody habitat, and the health of macroinvertebrates and fish. Their conclusion was clear: streamside forest buffers should be at least 100 feet wide on each side to adequately protect freshwater ecosystems from human activities.

Here are some of the reasons:

Clean water. Sediment is the single largest source of pollution in Pennsylvania streams. Sedimentation is the dirt, soil, and other small particles that are washed into our streams, lakes, and wetlands during heavy precipitation events. Sedimentation increases water cloudiness, reducing sunlight and oxygen for plants and aquatic animals, and raising water temperatures. Sedimentation, with or without additional contamination such as nitrogen and phosphorus, kills our streams and lakes.

Stroud found that buffers are key when it comes to reducing sedimentation. Vegetated riparian buffers about 33 feet wide trapped roughly 65% of sediment, while buffers about 98 feet trapped roughly 85%. This is a significant reduction, but clean water involves more than just removing sediment. For example, Nitrogen is a nutrient that is important for the growth of plants and animals, but too much of it in our waters can cause runaway growth of toxic algae and other problems. Nitrogen is tougher to catch because it dissolves in water instead of clinging to soil. On average, a 35-foot buffer trapped about 20% of nitrogen, and a 100-foot buffer trapped about 48%. Put another way, even at 100 feet, more than half the nitrogen still gets through, which tells us wider buffers still have real work left to do. Stroud concluded that nitrogen removal reached 90% only when a buffer exceeded 300 feet in width. All of this shows that the wider the buffer, the better it is at reducing sedimentation and pollution from erosion and runoff.

Cool water and healthy streams. The Stroud study found that fully protecting streams against temperature change requires vegetated buffers of at least about 100 feet, and that aquatic macroinvertebrate (water-dwelling animals that do not have a backbone and can be seen without a microscope) and fish communities stay near a natural state when buffered by at least that much forest.

Forests work in the stream, too. Buffers don’t just filter what’s running off the land. Stroud has also shown that the healthier streams created by forest buffers can process nutrients and organic matter two to eight times more effectively. That’s why forested buffers outperform grass: the trees make the stream itself better at cleaning water.

Flood control and wildlife. Other research points to even wider buffers for other jobs, like reducing flood impacts and protecting sensitive wildlife. Studies suggest buffers of at least 65 feet, and as wide as 500 feet, are required to meaningfully reduce flooding. Wildlife that lives between land and water, like frogs, turtles, and mink, generally needs buffers around 300 feet wide, and some species, such as herons and bald eagles, may need up to 600 feet. The bigger the buffer, the more protection it gives simply by being there.

Buffers that last. Width also affects whether a buffer holds up over time. A study of established buffers in Washington State found that nearly all buffers under 50 feet shrank significantly within a few years, and some lost their benefits entirely. Wider buffers held up far better, protecting the community, the stream, and the ecosystem for much longer.

So How Wide Is Wide Enough?

Put it all together, and the takeaway is simple: wider buffers accomplish more, do more jobs, and they do those jobs better. It’s worth remembering that Stroud’s 100 feet is a floor, not a ceiling. Their own data show buffers keep delivering more benefits well beyond that width. Drawing on the broader body of research, the Environmental Law Institute recommends minimum widths ranging from about 82 feet for pollutant removal to more than 330 feet for wildlife habitat. DEP’s own guidance gives a Pennsylvania-specific number. It advises a minimum of 150 feet for Exceptional Value and High Quality streams and 100 feet for other waters, with wider buffers where slopes are steep, soils erode easily, or fertilizer and manure are applied nearby.

Of course, science is one major part of the picture, but not the only one. The research tells us what streams need, and municipal policy has to balance that against other legitimate interests: the rights of property owners, the realities of small lots and existing homes, the scale of different projects, and a township’s capacity to administer and enforce its rules. A buffer standard that makes sense for a large warehouse site may not make sense for a family that wants to add a garage. Getting that balance right, making it protective where it matters most, and ensuring it is practical everywhere else, is critical for managing buffer policy. And that is exactly what our new Riparian Buffer Model Ordinance does. Our attorneys carefully crafted a tiered approach to buffer width requirements, recommending a 50-foot buffer for most residential and other small-scale development and stepping up to 100-foot and 150-foot buffers as the size of a project grows. We also recommend that municipalities strategically implement 300-foot buffers in areas of exceptional ecological importance. This approach strikes a balance that protects our waters, saves municipalities money, and respects the rights of landowners across the Commonwealth.